Time for WordPress Quality Control

Quality Control Needed For WordPress Plugins

WordPress PluginsIt is time WordPress.org introduced a quality control system to vet plugins available from the repository. There are so many faulty plugins that just simply do not work, or are not compatible with the later WordPress versions.

A system needs to be introduced whereby WordPress users can see immediately if a plugin will work the way the developer claims, if it is fully compatible with the version of WordPress in use. The user voting system does not work well enough – how many users actually bother to vote for a plugin – a very small percentage if we look at votes cast, and downloads of any plugin…

GPL and Free, Not OPEN FAULT

The WordPress plugins from the repository are free (mostly – although there are many that need paid subscriptions to enable full functions, but that is fine). But then so are Drupal Modules (plugins), and when we install a Drupal module we have a very good idea about the state of the developement of the plugin, whether it is considered stable, or is in some stage of development…

With WordPress being one of the most used systems for blogging, and catching up fast for website CMS use, the user friendly system has reached a level of maturity where GPL and free should no longer go hand in hand with open fault, unresolved but closed. Possibly more so for WordPress; the ease of set-up and content creation makes the system very attractive to non-technical users, many of whom have neither the time or inclination to delve into debugging plugins to get their sites to work properly.

Plugin Status Required

I repeat, users need to know the status of a plugin BEFORE they install it. A system whereby plugins that have not been vetted and found to have achieved a minimum required level of compatibility are indicated as such – Alpha stage, beta stage, unstable beta, not for production websites etc will benefit the WordPress user community as well as the developers.

Many of us with technical skills are quite wiling to install in-development plugins, and provide feedback to the developers, even work on fixing the faults we find (which are often specific to some hosting solutions, combinations of other plugins or themes) provided we know to expect problems. I for one get annoyed when expecting a trouble-free function, then find the plugin is faulty. When this happens, and it does all too often, I am more likely to trash the plugin and use something else.

Several WordPress Plugins with major problems:

Over the past few weeks I have come across a rash of WordPress Plugins with problemsbroken plugins including caching and performance plugins, and RSS plugins.

WP Super Cache Plugin:

WP Super Cache is one that really should not have the faults I experienced. It has been downloaded nearly 1 million times, WP super cacheand is highly rated and recommended. But the latest version is broken – at least with some WordPress set-ups, and some similar problems seem to affect versions after 0.8.

Today I found this plugin works on only 33% of the sites I used it on… On one live site the pre-load function only caches taxonomy pages… On another live site it just doesn’t work. The only site it looked like it was working correctly was a basic testing set-up (with no other plugins to cause conflict, and a very basic theme – not good at all). and this site and the second site mentioned are hosted on the SAME SERVER – with identical server settings, so is not a server configuration problem.

RSS in Page Plugins:

Looking for a plugin to load RSS feed into pages last week I came across three of these that do not work at all… The fourth one did – HungryFEED

Other Performance Plugins with Faults

WP Minify – to combine multiple CSS and Java files broke one site completely (Thesis theme) and caused style problems with another site (OK, the guilty CSS file can be excluded from the minify function)

Use Google Libraries also failed to work on the same two sites – in one case it only hooked into one Googleapi java script file – and that one could not have been the same as the result was broken functionality… And with no method to exclude the files causing problems.

The modules I use for both these functions with Drupal 7 work perfectly, even though when I first installed them, both were in alpha or beta development stages… and clearly indicated as such.

IDXpro Plugin

IDXpro plugin for WPrdPress only works for some regions – or more specifically the multi listing search is only VISIBLE to viewers in some parts of the world… For all the rest it causes the page downlaod to never complete… The plugin is available from the wordPress repository – it shouldn’t be as it is completely useless without signing up for the service…

Users cannot vote if it works or not, and cannot post reports if the IDXpro plugin is broken – they just get re-directed to the WordPress forum tag-cloud page – WordPress should consider this plugin in contravention of the GPL requirement – and force the developers to clearly explain it’s limitations – i.e. it only works for about 1 percent of the world’s internet users (site visitors). The company behind it makes no mention of the limitation of the service on their audience restricted website -see  IDXPro MLS Not Working.

me on google plus+Mike Otgaar


About Mike

Web Developer and Techno-geek Saltwater fishing nut Blogger

Posted on February 9, 2012, in TECHNOLOGY, WordPress and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 2 Comments.

  1. Use Google Libraries will sometimes not load libraries from Google by design, to avoid breaking your site. Also I can’t think of any plugin incompatibility report with UGL that hasn’t been caused by the other plugin, usually from not following the documented way to enqueue scripts.

    • Thanks for the input Jason…
      WP is still a great system, even if a few plugins conflict with each other and with some themes, and is the system I recommend to most of my clients (small business owners form the majority of my clients) for a website…
      My comments may sound harsh, but are intended as constructive criticsm.
      Many customers want an installation at the lowest possible cost – debugging, customising and hardcoding to prevent conflicts etc adds to the basic set-up cost for these customers. When I hand over a new site I want my customers to have an enjoyable experience with WordPress, without having to call me too often to solve problems for them (That may sound strange as I get paid for this extra work).
      WP is used by many who lack the technical knowledge and don’t have the time to learn the finer points – they just want a website that works, is easy to add content to, and maintain. (I should have emphasized this perhaps).
      Once again, kudos to all the plugin authors out there

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: